Re-Formed In Charity: My Book Review Of The Generous Parish 

by Books | Our Favorite Catholic Books To Read

“Never measure your generosity by what you give, but rather by what you have left.”

— Blessed Fulton J. Sheen

Over the last two years, reading Abandonment to Divine Providence has given me insight into the theological virtue of charity. At first glance, you might expect a book on divine providence to focus solely on receiving God’s wellsprings of love. But as you venture deeper, it emphasizes a transformative truth: when we love according to God’s will, there is absolutely no limit to what He can do in a soul. You become airborne. You begin to resemble Christ Himself.

That spiritual truth also directly connects to what St. Paul writes in his first letter to the Corinthians: you can possess every spiritual gift, speak in tongues, and carry immense talent, but if you do not have love—if you lack charity—you are nothing. Generosity is, therefore, not a transaction; it is how we live out love in real time.

It is through this lens that I recently read a most eye-opening book: The Generous Parish, written by eCatholic’s Evangelist, Brandon Duncan.

Clocking in at under 120 pages, it is a bite-sized read that you can easily digest in a few sittings. Yet, beneath its brevity lies a masterclass in spiritual formation that is practical, down-to-earth, and entirely repeatable for pastors and parish leaders.

A Soul Reset, Not a Corporate Campaign

Giving is a subject that most pastors were simply never trained on during their years in seminary. Priests pour their whole hearts into their vocations, yet we must acknowledge that few were ever taught how to invite the hearts of their flock—and yes, their checkbooks—to truly support their home parishes.

That is where The Generous Parish steps in. As Brandon Duncan, the book’s author, frequently highlights, stewardship is a matter of the soul before it is ever a matter of a budget. What this book offers is not a clever mindset trick or a marketing campaign. It is a total soul reset.

It gives leaders a framework to cultivate a recurring spirit of charity within parishioners while grounding everything in the deep theology behind why we give. I value how it shifts the paradigm away from feeling like we have to give out of obligation, moving us toward recognizing that we get to give to our local spiritual homes.

Crucially, the book doesn’t rely on scriptural guilt-trips or manipulative scripts designed to tug on heartstrings. Instead, it anchors right in the rich tradition of the Church, drawing from Thomas Aquinas and early Church Fathers like Basil the Great, Ambrose of Milan, and John Chrysostom.

My Favorite Two Chapters

Split into three parts and 12 chapters, the book naturally moves from The Theology of Giving into the pastoral art of Building a Generous Parish. It challenges you to become the kind of leader—and build the kind of community—where generosity grows the way fruit grows on a healthy tree: naturally, abundantly, because the underlying conditions are finally right.

Two chapters grabbed my heart in a special way:

  • Chapter 3: “The Sin Often Overlooked.” Avarice (greed) —oops, did O’Maria just give away a spoiler!?—often goes unconfessed in our churches for a simple, troubling reason: nobody recognizes it in themselves. Unlike sins that scream out with obvious moments of failure, avarice is a quiet condition. It settles into a life so gradually, disguising itself so cleverly as prudence and responsibility, that a soul can be wholly in its grip without ever noticing it.
  • Chapter 8: “Building a Culture, Not Running a Campaign.” After naming overlooked sins comes reforming the culture that unknowingly bred them. The truth is that the Church has taught more effectively through her saints than through dry arguments. The Generous Parish examines what happens when someone lives out their theology—pointing to Francis of Assisi stripping off his fine clothes in the public square of Assisi, Elizabeth of Hungary, Katharine Drexel, and many others.

All of this boils down to a single, beautiful reversal—the hinge on which a parishioner’s relationship with money turns. It comes down to two questions we can ponder:

  • The unconverted question: “How much do I have to give?” (A question that quietly begrudges the gift).
  • The converted question: “How much do I get to keep?” (A question that marvels that so much has been entrusted to our care).

Pastoral Acts That Build a Giving Culture

Here is the liberating truth for any pastor or faith-curious community leader reading this: 

You do not need to become a fundraiser or apologize your way through an annual financial appeal. 

You simply need to teach what the Church already believes with the same quiet confidence you bring to the Eucharist or the moral law.

Generosity flourishes when a parish is shepherded. People do not follow a stranger. The Generous Parish highlights pastoral acts that do the heaviest lifting:

  1. Preaching with Personal Conviction: A homily preached by a man who clearly believes what he is saying grips the soul differently than one that is merely well-constructed. When a pastor lets the Gospel touch his own heart before organizing his words, he speaks with an authority no rhetorical technique or AI agent can manufacture. Thus, a homily on the widow’s mite delivered by a pastor who has examined his own heart will do far more for a parish than any high-pressure financial drive.
  2. The Witness of John Vianney: Along with pastoral zeal, our beloved Curé of Ars provides the ultimate proof of concept in parish history. He didn’t run stewardship campaigns; he simply tended his flock with total, holy devotion, and the parish responded with everything they had. A pastor who aims at that witness will find that his parish’s generosity follows his sanctity the way a shadow follows the light. 

In a Nutshell 

I believe that The Generous Parish is a vehicle for igniting our leaders to be Christ’s hands and feet in the world. By shifting our perspective from arithmetic to faith, and from leftovers to first fruits, it reminds us that giving is a sacred privilege. We get to give. 

So, if you are a pastor, business manager, communications director, finance council member, or a faith-curious leader looking to build a culture grounded in genuine charity, this book is an invaluable map for your journey ahead. As you decide to imbibe its insights, may you resolve to measure not your generosity by what you give, but instead, by what you have left. 

Blessed Fulton J. Sheen, pray for us!

The Generous Parish: A Guide to Cultivate a More Generous Flock for the Church is now available as a free download or in paperback on Amazon. 

Keep Searching, Keep Learning

Our Newest Articles:

Solemnity Of All Saints Gospel Reflection

Solemnity Of All Saints Gospel Reflection

When Jesus saw the crowds, he went up the mountain,and after he had sat down, his disciples came to him.He began to teach them, saying:"Blessed are the poor in spirit,for theirs is the Kingdom of heaven.Blessed are they who mourn,for they will be comforted.Blessed are...

Grow in Faith with Catholic-Link.org!

Grow in Faith with Catholic-Link.org!

Get our best Catholic articles, practical faith resources, and seasonal inspiration delivered to your inbox each week.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest